The United States and Russia are preparing to oppose efforts to establish legally binding international rules on lethal autonomous weapons, creating a major challenge for diplomats gathering in Geneva to discuss the future of artificial intelligence in warfare.
The United Nations-hosted Seventh Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons began on November 16 and is scheduled to run until November 20. One of its central issues is whether countries should move towards negotiations on an international instrument regulating autonomous weapons systems.
These systems can select and attack targets with varying degrees of human involvement. Their growing capabilities have raised questions about military accountability, civilian protection and whether existing international humanitarian law is sufficient to address the risks.
The disagreement is not simply about technology. It concerns who should retain control over decisions involving human life during armed conflict.
What are lethal autonomous weapons?
Lethal autonomous weapons systems, commonly known as LAWS, are weapons that can select and engage targets without direct human intervention in the final decision to attack.
The level of autonomy can vary. Some systems require human approval before an attack, while others may operate with greater independence once activated.
Artificial intelligence and advanced automation have increased interest in systems involving drones, robotic platforms, military vehicles and other equipment capable of processing information and responding to battlefield conditions.
The central concern is that a machine could make a decision to attack without meaningful human judgment at the moment force is used.
That creates difficult questions. Can a system reliably distinguish civilians from combatants? Can it understand whether a person is surrendering? Who is responsible if its decision causes an unlawful attack?
These are among the issues international discussions are attempting to address.
Why the Geneva meeting matters
The conference taking place from November 16 to 20 is the seventh review conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons.
According to the United Nations Office at Geneva, the meeting is held every five years and provides an opportunity for countries to assess the operation of the convention and address developments in weapons technology.
The convention already regulates or prohibits several categories of conventional weapons considered excessively injurious or indiscriminate in their effects.
It currently has 128 high contracting parties.
The autonomous-weapons discussion follows the work of the Group of Governmental Experts on emerging technologies in the area of lethal autonomous weapons systems.
That group adopted a final report on September 4, 2026, containing elements of a possible international instrument and other measures for addressing the technology.
The review conference is expected to consider that work and determine the next steps for international discussions.
The UN says the conference represents an important opportunity to make progress towards negotiations.
Why Washington and Moscow oppose binding restrictions
Reuters reported on November 16 that the United States, Russia and Israel oppose legally binding rules, arguing that existing international humanitarian law provides an adequate framework.
The United States favours guidelines and has proposed a five-year mandate for negotiations towards a non-binding agreement.
The chair of the Geneva discussions, meanwhile, has proposed a two-year mandate to negotiate a legally binding protocol.
The United Kingdom, Germany and France support negotiations on an instrument while leaving its eventual legal status open.
Russia has previously resisted proposals for a binding agreement, although Reuters reported that Moscow had not publicly stated its complete position ahead of the meeting.
The different approaches reveal the challenge facing negotiators.
Countries supporting binding rules want clearer restrictions and prohibitions. Others prefer a framework that leaves more flexibility for military development and national security policies.
A non-binding agreement could establish common expectations without creating the same legal obligations as a treaty or protocol.
A binding agreement would potentially provide a stronger legal framework, but reaching consensus among major military powers could be more difficult.
Why humanitarian organisations are concerned
The International Committee of the Red Cross has called for stronger international action on autonomous weapons.
In a paper published on November 13 ahead of the Geneva conference, the organisation outlined its recommendations on several humanitarian issues covered by the convention, including autonomous weapons.
The ICRC’s wider position emphasises the need to preserve human judgment and control over the use of force.
The United Nations also says autonomous weapons raise concerns about civilian protection, compliance with humanitarian law and human accountability.
The risks are not limited to technical malfunction.
A system may function exactly as designed but still produce a decision that is unacceptable under humanitarian principles. The ability to identify a target does not automatically mean a machine can understand the wider circumstances surrounding that target.
The unpredictability of some systems and the possibility of fatal errors have therefore become central concerns.
Reuters also reported that AI-assisted weapons have been used in conflicts including Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East.
The precise capabilities and levels of autonomy differ between systems, so the use of AI-assisted weapons should not automatically be equated with fully autonomous lethal decision-making.
What could happen next?
Diplomats are considering several possible outcomes, including a legally binding agreement, non-binding guidelines or a hybrid arrangement.
The discussions are expected to be difficult because states disagree about the legal form, scope and level of control required.
A compromise could allow negotiations to continue without resolving every disagreement immediately.
However, delaying decisions also means that military technology may continue developing while international rules remain incomplete.
The Geneva conference is therefore an important moment for the future of military AI governance.
Its outcome will help determine whether governments move closer to common restrictions on autonomous weapons or continue relying primarily on existing legal frameworks and national policies.
The underlying question remains difficult but increasingly urgent: as machines become more capable of selecting targets, how much responsibility and decision-making authority should remain with humans?
Reader Discussion (0)
Join the Bangladeshist Community
Sign in with your Google account to post comments, reply to fellow readers, and engage in informed discussions.